Summary
- 87% of respondents believe modern slavery is likely to be occurring somewhere in their value chain and 55% have identified actual or suspected cases in the past three years.
- Almost three quarters say the Modern Slavery Act has increased the focus on reporting rather than action, while 90% identify the absence of mandatory human rights due diligence as a weakness.
- HR leaders need to look beyond direct employees to agency, temporary and outsourced workers, strengthen labour-provider and recruitment practices and measure whether action is improving outcomes for workers
It is more than 10 years since the Modern Slavery Act was introduced in the UK. New research from Hult International Business School has looked at what’s changed in how organisations engage with modern slavery, and what lessons have emerged for senior business leaders and others.
One key finding from the research is that organisations that uncover and disclose exploitation may face greater reputational and legal risks than those which do very little to investigate it. What does this tell senior leaders about the gap between corporate policies and actual working conditions, particularly for workers outside an organisation's direct employment relationships? We look at the implications of all this for HR leaders.
Why modern slavery remains a mainstream business risk
Modern slavery is widespread. Ten years ago few even knew what the term really referred to, and if they did, they assumed it was a distant problem, somewhere else. Today, 87% of the organisations surveyed believe modern slavery is likely to be occurring somewhere in their value chain, and 55% have identified actual or suspected cases in the past three years.
The human suffering of modern slavery is clear and should have no place in any organisation or its value chain. The business risks are also significant, ranging from reputational damage to disruption of supply. Forced labour import bans in the US and other jurisdictions make supply chain visibility and strong supplier relationships increasingly important.
While some businesses have taken steps to identify, prevent and mitigate modern slavery, many others have not. A key aspiration of the Modern Slavery Act was to raise awareness and encourage more consistent action across the board.
Why disclosure can create greater risk for organisations that investigate
In this context it is something of a perverse outcome that some organisations which uncover and disclose exploitation may face greater reputational and legal risks than those doing very little to investigate it.
Our research suggests this is partly down to how businesses organise their response, as well as weaknesses in the framing of the regulation itself. The UK government has recently announced its intention to introduce new regulation requiring organisations to carry out human rights due diligence, which should complement the Modern Slavery Act and address some of its weaknesses. But there are also important lessons for business leaders about things to do differently in their own organisations.
The Hult research, Corporate Leadership on Modern Slavery, found that over the last ten years some organisations have invested significant energy and resource in addressing modern slavery, including developing policies, supplier codes of conduct, reporting systems and training programmes.
Governance structures have also been created, with senior leaders and boards reviewing and signing modern slavery statements. In some organisations this has prompted meaningful discussion; in others it has become little more than a compliance exercise. In many settings resources are focused on producing the public statement required by the Act, with little remaining to actually invest in identifying, preventing and addressing modern slavery itself. Those that invest in doing so, and disclose what they find, can end up facing greater reputational risks than those that do not.
What helps organisations make progress on modern slavery
What accounts for these patterns? The organisations making the most progress typically combined the Modern Slavery Act with a wider set of incentives and accountability mechanisms.
Senior leaders understood the human and business risks involved and were supported by teams with expertise in human rights and modern slavery as well as the ability to interpret the Act and use it as a driver within the organisation. B2B customers, investors and owners also increased incentives to act through procurement decisions and access to capital. Investor benchmarks comparing organisations' approaches to modern slavery were cited as particularly influential, while participation in cross-sector initiatives was an important factor in the quality of an organisation’s approach.
The importance of these wider pressures is reflected in the findings: 96% of respondents said cross-sector collaboration would be helpful, while 85% said benchmarking organisations against each other would help strengthen action.
Why the Modern Slavery Act can drive reporting over action
Where these wider factors were absent the Act often had much less impact, tending to drive minimum compliance through publication of a statement and little work to identify, prevent and mitigate modern slavery.
The limitations of the Act are clear. It requires publication of a statement rather than action, penalties for poor compliance are weak, and resources can become focused on reporting rather than substantive work. Almost three quarters of respondents said the Act had increased focus on reporting rather than action, while 90% identified the lack of mandatory human rights due diligence requirements as a weakness.
The result is that while some organisations are taking meaningful action to address modern slavery risks, many are not. Yet it is often those organisations that are most transparent about what they are finding that attract greater scrutiny. For many, the current balance of incentives rewards disclosure less than silence.
How to measure modern slavery outcomes, not just activity
Even where action is occurring within organisations, many are finding they have not quite got the right balance of accountability mechanisms. While the Act has increased internal accountability in some organisations through requiring a board-approved modern slavery statement, accountability is often focused on process rather than outcomes - counting policies, codes of conduct and training programmes - but not outcomes for workers across the value chain.
Supplier audits, while useful for addressing some other ESG concerns, are much more limited for identifying problems of forced labour. There are also cases where an organisation's own purchasing practices undermine its efforts to address modern slavery. Risks often arise not simply because suppliers ignore standards, but because commercial arrangements create conditions that increase vulnerability. Different parts of the same business may be sending contradictory signals to suppliers.
What business and HR leaders should do now
What does all this mean for what organisations and others need to do now? What role should HR leaders play?
The findings have implications for policymakers, investors and customers alike. Proposed human rights due diligence requirements should help improve incentives for action, while stronger scrutiny from investors and customers can encourage organisations to prioritise modern slavery risks. More than four in five respondents believed stronger investor scrutiny would improve organisational responses to modern slavery.
What business leaders should change
There are also important implications for business leaders.
The starting point is understanding the issue itself. Modern slavery can still be viewed as a specialist compliance concern, but the findings suggest it should be considered a mainstream business risk. Nearly nine in ten respondents believe modern slavery is likely to be occurring somewhere within their value chain and more than half have identified actual or suspected cases in recent years.
Leaders need to invest in the organisational capability required to identify and address these risks. This means building accountability mechanisms focused on outcomes as well as activities. In other words, organisations need systems that provide visibility of what is actually happening to workers, not just whether policies have been published or training completed.
A related challenge is creating an environment where transparency is valued. The organisations making the greatest progress are often those that encourage honesty about problems rather than punishing those who uncover them. Businesses should create incentives that reward transparency and learning, helping people raise concerns and identify risks before they become crises.
Senior leaders also need to ensure that incentives are aligned across the organisation. Efforts to address modern slavery can easily be undermined if purchasing practices, commercial targets or supplier management processes create pressures that increase vulnerability among workers. Different parts of the business should be working towards consistent objectives and sending consistent signals throughout the value chain.
The research also highlights the importance of collaborative approaches. Many of the organisations seen as making the most progress were active participants in cross-sector initiatives and partnerships. These forums help organisations share learning, build capability and address challenges that no single organisation can solve alone.
Perhaps most importantly, organisations need to rethink how they respond when exploitation is uncovered. The solution to the current paradox is not less transparency. Organisations should be rewarded for identifying and addressing problems, rather than discouraged to look too closely. Stakeholders also need to distinguish clearly between discovering exploitation and failing to address exploitation once it has been identified.
What HR leaders should do about modern slavery risk
For HR leaders the findings are equally significant. Modern slavery is not just an issue within global supply chains. Risks can arise much closer to home, including within direct operations and among temporary, agency and outsourced workers. The research found increasing concern about outsourced workforces, including functions such as construction, facilities management, cleaning, recruitment, security and logistics. Around 65% of respondents believed there was a high or extremely high likelihood of modern slavery risks within outsourced workforces.
This means HR leaders have an important role to play in strengthening recruitment practices, reviewing the use of labour providers and ensuring workers can raise concerns safely.
HR leaders are also well placed to help build engagement and capability across the organisation. Recruiting individuals with the ability to interpret complex modern slavery and human rights requirements for the organisation as well as establish process, structures and engagement to support the approach is crucial, The research also found that 69% of respondents believed the Modern Slavery Act had increased senior leader engagement with the issue, yet 92% believed further education and awareness-raising for senior leaders would help improve organisational responses. Building understanding among boards and executive teams therefore remains an important priority.
Finally, HR leaders can help organisations move beyond measuring activity to measuring outcomes. Policies, training programmes and reporting processes all have value, but they are only meaningful if they contribute to improvements in workers’ lives. The organisations making the greatest progress are increasingly focused on understanding whether people can raise concerns safely, whether exploitation is being identified earlier, and whether action being taken is actually making a difference.
Some 10 years on from the Modern Slavery Act that may be the most important lesson of all. Progress depends not simply on creating policies, publishing statements or demonstrating compliance, but on building organisations that are capable of identifying exploitation, responding to it and learning from what they find. The challenge for business and HR leaders is to ensure that the incentives, accountability mechanisms and culture within their organisations support that goal.
The Hult report draws on 38 in-depth interviews and a survey of 57 managers working in modern slavery, ethical trade, human rights, procurement, legal compliance and related roles.
FAQs on Modern Slavery
Why can companies that disclose modern slavery face greater risk?
Organisations that investigate their operations and value chains thoroughly are more likely to uncover and disclose exploitation. That can expose them to reputational and legal scrutiny, while organisations doing less investigation may reveal fewer problems. Hult's research argues that the current balance of incentives can therefore reward silence more than transparency.
What does Hult's research identify as a weakness of the Modern Slavery Act?
The research suggests the Act can concentrate organisational attention on publishing statements rather than identifying, preventing and addressing exploitation. Almost three quarters of respondents said it had increased the focus on reporting rather than action and 90% identified the lack of mandatory human rights due diligence requirements as a weakness.
What should HR leaders do about modern slavery risk?
HR leaders should look beyond the directly employed workforce. Risks can arise among temporary, agency and outsourced workers, making recruitment practices, labour providers, safe routes for raising concerns and senior leader understanding important. HR can also help shift measurement away from policies and training completed towards whether exploitation is being identified earlier and outcomes for workers are improving.
About the author