BT–TalkTalk: why the hardest part of a rescue deal comes next

BT's TalkTalk rescue deal raises questions about workforce integration, employee retention and the organisational knowledge that acquisition plans can overlook
Published on
Image
People working on a myriad of screens and whiteboards bringing data from two organisations together

Summary

BT's rescue acquisition of TalkTalk highlights the workforce integration risks that can be overlooked in distressed deals. As BT prepares to absorb around 900 employees Nick Petschek of Kotter examines why retaining organisational knowledge, involving frontline employees and testing integration plans against operational realities are critical to making acquisitions work. The challenge extends beyond financial due diligence to protecting the people, relationships and expertise on which business continuity depends.

BT’s recent rescue acquisition of TalkTalk has sparked controversy across the industry. Government has intervened and competitors and investment funds have fiercely criticised the deal for being unjust and anti-competitive. But beyond the public dispute over the fairness of the deal, BT has another pressing issue right now; bringing across 900 people from rival TalkTalk and integrating two disparate enterprises is the real challenge here. Are acquisition plans sufficient to successfully combine former rival workforces and processes, particularly when due diligence is rushed and change-readiness overlooked?

Why workforce integration is the real acquisition challenge

The acquisition of TalkTalk, while complex and high-profile, is arguably not the hardest part of this deal. The complexities BT faces in absorbing the TalkTalk workforce, operations and customers, and keeping employees stable and motivated while it begins to implement its merger strategy, ultimately present the biggest challenge. After years of restructuring, job cuts and a failed sale process, staff morale at TalkTalk is likely to be low. The risk for BT is that staff leave, taking with them valuable, undocumented knowledge of TalkTalk’s systems and customer operations. Losing these specialists could threaten service continuity – one of the key justifications for the rescue deal.

What due diligence misses about people and organisational knowledge

With a failing business and the clock ticking, rescue acquisitions concentrate on assets, liabilities and regulatory clearance. Unquantifiable yet critical assessment of staff goodwill, cultural fit, undocumented know-how and informal ways of working do not make it onto the balance sheet. While legal protections are put in place to protect employees’ terms, such as Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment - TUPE), they do not safeguard employee commitment. Yet much of what keeps an organisation functioning depends on employees' experience, informal working relationships and knowledge of how to deal with problems that aren't captured in formal processes or due diligence. In a distressed busines people are ultimately the most valuable asset.

How leaders can use a regulatory pause to improve integration

Deals like this often happen too fast for anyone to ask whether the workforce is ready, but this regulatory pause gives BT a valuable opportunity to listen first, then shape the integration around what it learns. Rather than introducing a fixed plan from the outset, shorter sprints would allow BT to set immediate priorities and work towards them, assess how the changes are working, and adapt its approach as it learns more about the workforce and business.

Important steps can be taken within this period to listen to and involve TalkTalk and PXC staff and better understand what they believe the deal will mean for them, and what other value may have been left on the table. Critically, it also provides an important opportunity to stress-test the business case and address the demands and reality of the integration plan with the people who will deliver it. By running the assumptions on retention, systems migration and customer service past the frontline teams and getting their views on potential vulnerabilities, BT can not only gather important insight from TalkTalk management and staff, but also build confidence and allegiance with its new, extended team.

Why frontline employees need to shape integration plans

It may sound obvious but open conversations and proactively involving employees across the acquired business are paramount to a successful integration, however rushed or distressed the acquisition may be.

For example, during the integration of two insurance firms an ‘urgency team’ of mediators was set up to explain the reasons for the deal to employees and respond to concerns. Although senior leadership at the acquiring company had emphasised the need for collaboration between the two organisations, the urgency team discovered that while people were willing to work together the infrastructure was preventing them from doing so. Staff had to log out and back in usingdifferent credentials across multiple systems, making it time-consuming and, for some workers, technically impossible. Senior management committed to resolving the issue immediately; it was a simple fix that made a monumental impact on integration.

Although IT collaboration had been part of the integration plan it had not been flagged as a priority because frontline workers had not been involved in the integration planning discussions. If so they would have immediately flagged the barriers to their day-to-day work had they been involved. This illustrates why leaders need to look beyond the deal itself and understand how their decisions affect the people expected to make the integration work.

How leaders can create the conditions for successful integration

Delivering on an acquisition presents challenges for any company. With distressed deals these challenges are even greater. Once the merger starts competing demands collide, plans meet reality and each department sees something slightly different. Teams become stretched, uncertainty builds and there is a tendency for decisions to become centralised. Good leadership can make the difference. What matters, however, is not just the choices leaders make, but the conditions they create. This is linked to our survive/thrive theory, a model which explains how people embrace or resist change. It outlines how leaders can ensure they appropriately balance a reactive “survive” with a more positive, forward-looking “thrive” mindset by creating the conditions that promote this response. Both are needed, but Thrive typically requires more intention to promote.

Choosing change leaders from both organisations and offering employees at every level of the organisation a role in shaping integration is key. People support what they build, so bringing them into the transition will not only make for a swifter transition but also build loyalty. It is also important to offer a level of autonomy across departments. By allowing the newly merged HR departments to work together to implement the integration plan and by granting them the freedom to work in the best way they see fit, they can provide an important example to other departments to emulate.

Leaders should also be vocal in acknowledging the culture shift. In TalkTalk’s case, moving from challenger to incumbent is an identity change for staff that should not be ignored. Similarly, small achievements that matter to staff should be shouted about - for example, fixing a disliked tool or ending uncertainty about roles. Empathising with employees will help to build trust and facilitate the introduction of bigger changes further down the line.

Ultimately, the success of a rescue deal lies largely in how integration is led and managed. Acquisition plans go a long way in identifying financial weaknesses and potential opportunities, but the real work begins once the deal is signed:bringing two entities together with different cultures, systems and ways of working together. Not every integration will deliver return on investment, but leaders can improve the chances by understanding the acquired workforce’s perspective, recognising the sensitivities involved, and creating iterative and collaborative plans that can adapt as the business changes. Crucially, their responsibility does not end when the integration is complete. Sustained leadership is needed to turn a troubled deal into a fruitful one.

About the author

Nick Petschek of Kotter Headshot
Nick Petschek

Nick Petschek leads Kotter's EMEA business and is a member of the Research and Development leadership team with Dr John Kotter. He has led business transformations in organisations big and small, including household names such as Apple, the NFL and 3M, and has worked in 20+ countries. He has advised executives in transportation, pharma, utilities, insurance, healthcare, and public sectors. Petschek holds a dual Master of Arts degree in International Affairs from The Fletcher School and Urban Planning, both from Tufts University, and is co-author of upcoming book The Adaptive Organization

View Articles

Related articles