Young, thin and Caucasian? Step this way. Older, heavier and being interviewed by someone of a different race? There’s the door
Bias is alive and kicking among hiring professionals, finds employer review company Fairygodboss
Women are still judged by their appearance, according to research from employer review company Fairygodboss which surveyed 500 recruitment professionals by showing them photos of 15 different female job candidates.
Respondents were asked to choose the top three out of 11 adjectives they felt described each woman. They were then asked to choose the five women they would be most likely to hire.
The candidate most frequently selected by recruitment managers was a young, thin, Caucasian brunette. Women of different races, sizes or with less traditional appearances were less likely to be chosen.
A fifth of the recruitment managers surveyed described the photo of the heaviest-looking women as ‘lazy’, 21% described her as ‘unprofessional’ and only 18% said she had ‘leadership potential’. Just 15.6% would consider hiring her.
Older women were considered to have positive traits and characteristics, ranking sixth for professionalism, third for leadership material and first for reliability. These were the three traits the hiring managers listed as most important in a potential recruit. Yet less than 30% of those surveyed said they would hire the older woman and she came 10th overall for hireability.
Meanwhile, the top choices of job candidates were women of the recruitment manager’s own race. So, the top three choices of white respondents were white women while over two-thirds of African American respondents listed the African American candidate as one of their top choices and 61.5% of Asian respondents chose the Asian woman as the best candidate.
Race also played a factor in how the women were evaluated for leadership potential. Recruitment managers were more inclined to believe job candidates of their own race possessed leadership potential.
Fairygodboss suggests that women be wary of biases to decrease their chances of being superficially judged during the hiring process.
“Wearing a different suit jacket won’t make hiring managers overlook your age or your race. But being informed about people’s biases can help you try to counteract a few things that may be within your control,” they say.
Wearing a different suit jacket won’t make hiring managers overlook your age or your race